(1894, One-With-A-Little-Light-On Press)
Long-overlooked by Chesleyan scholars, this modern fairy tale is arguably one of Chesley’s most influential works.
Chesley wrote this sometime in the spring and summer of 1894, while she was travelling in the UK with her uncle, the infamous cranial traumatist (and inventor) Michael Flannigan. Like her spectacularly unsuccessful BUNGYWASH FABLES, THE PENURIOUS PANIC POOKIE OF PORTH is somewhat inspired by the work of Charles Lutwidge Dodgson, AKA, Lewis Carroll. [1]
As with many of her children’s tales, the story follows a young girl transported to a strange land, where she encounters a host of colourful and seemingly nonsensical characters. The protagonist is Dorothy Bestley, an orphan living with her uncle and spinster aunts in County Perth, Ontario. One day, a powerful snowstorm whisks her and her pony, Bragi, off the ground and deposits them in the Place of Porth. Initially disoriented, Dorothy soon discovers that as an outsider, she is only one who can save the Place of Porth from the evil machinations of the Penurious Panic Pookie. [2]
The pookie lives in the Golden City, where he controls the spending habits of its denizens through the use of fear, intimidation and something called “the Fical Pol”. Upon arrival, Dorothy’s pony crushes Baron Fudgestick, a thinly disguised stand in for Chesley’s arch-enemy (at this time), Quentin Farkmee. When she picks up Fudgestick’s tiny wand of silver, a starving horde of tiny mustachioed soldiers ask her to save them from the penury of the pookie. If she can insert the silver wand into the heart of the Golden Circle, and fill its circumference, then the pookie’s power can be broken. Unfortunately, the silver wand is much too small to fill the Golden Circle as it is, so she must follow the Road of Iron and complete many tasks so that the silver wand is properly engorged.
Riding away on Bragi, Dorothy soon discovers that in many places, the Road of Iron is washed out. At the first break in the road, she meets Stuffing, a lamb who has been shorn of all his fleece by the Pookie, and who desperately wants it back. She asks Stuffing to tag along, suggesting that once the Pookie’s power has been broken, he can be “refleeced”. Soon they meet Busy, a giant, industrious rat, who has had all of his workman’s tools stolen by the Pookie. He joins them so he can get his tools back and so get his manufactory working again. Finally, they meet Craven, a banker who was so frightened that he would run out of money, he has given it all to the Pookie for safe keeping. This foursome (plus the pony Bragi [3) then go on to have a series of adventures in which they are all terrorized and frightened by the Pookie until eventually, they discover the Pool of Confidence. They all have a jolly, rollicking bath together, and Dorothy's silver wand grows to gigantic proportions; her new friends recover their fleece, tools and money respectively. When the Pookie returns to steal them back, Dorothy inserts the wand into the Golden Circle, thus breaking the Pookie's power. As the Pookie shrinks away, it says ominously, "you've got me this cycle, but I'll be back!"
Dorothy then awakes back in Perth County, only to discover that it was all a hallucination brought on by bad peanuts fed to her by her uncle. [4]
Pookie is clearly an allegory about the Panic of 1893 and the ensuing economic depression that set in afterward, with Stuffing representing the farming classes, Busy the out-of-work employees of the industrial sector, and Craven the entire banking industry who’s pant-staining fear led to the closure of many banks, a general credit crunch and millions of middle-class people abandoning their Victorian houses as they could no longer pay the mortgage. The Road of Iron refers to the “railroad” bubble — a period of irrational enthusiasm which led to overbuilding and bad financing. Ironically, this bubble was supported by bimetallism, or pegging the dollar to both gold and silver, thus explaining why the Fudgestick’s “silver wand” is so tiny. [5]
While the publisher was quite excited about the book, it was not well received by the public. In particular, the “bathing” scene, where Dorothy is forced to sit on the engorged wand of silver to keep it from floating away incensed many as “blatantly naughty”. However, copies did find its way into public libraries across the continent; in Chicago, one Frank L. Baum took out the book and never returned it, as it was one of his favourite things to read during his lonely nights on the road as a travelling salesman. [6] The similarities between Pookie and The Wizard of Oz are too direct to miss. As an allegory, it is possible that Baum’s work is even better than Chesley’s, though as a work of imaginative fiction, Pookie displays a greater facility with language, more inventive wordplay (similar to Lewis Carroll’s work), and a series of incidents which can be interpreted on several levels, many of which are quite salacious and disturbing.
It is because of this fact THE PENURIOUS PANIC POOKIE OF PORTH was one of the first books which was burned in the great Victorian Park Bonfire of 1905, though it was hardly the only novel penned by Chesley to add fuel to that memorable fire.
Notes:
[1] Chesley actually met Dodgson in the summer of 1893 while accompanying her uncle, who had been invited to the UK for a barmy lecture tour at the behest of the British Society of Insane Inventors (later known as the Mad Society of Mad Scientists Society Gobble Bobble Rachamach). The tour was to have profound literary consequences. While in Bigone-on-Tyne, explaining how the Pornograph had come to be stolen by another inventor, an aging Charles Dogdson was keen to show the famous creator of the “Introspection Wheel” one of his own devices — the Nyctograph, a device for taking notes in bed (or while under the influence of mind-altering substances, as he often was.) While discussing the vagaries of patent law, Dogdson invited Flannigan over for tea.
“Would ye’ mind if I brought along me darlin’ niece?” Flannigan asked.
“Of course, of course,” said Dogdson, his eyes sparkling in anticipation, “I shall have my camera at the ready.” (Dogdson was a camera enthusiast, and borderline pervert who like to take pictures of young girls.)
Dogdson was somewhat disappointed to find that Emily was fully grown (and spectacularly, if the journals of the 7th Regiment are to be believed). He was delighted, however, to find a fellow-traveler in speculative literature. While her uncle rifled through Dogdson’s notes describing the Nyctograph (which is uncannily similar to Flannigan’s 1894 Automatic Pen) the two writers shared a pipe of something that Flannigan’s friend, Gunter Gruntz, would no doubt have recognized if he wasn’t thoroughly decomposed.
[2] This probably comes from ” Púca”, which in old Irish is a shape-changing fairy who terrorizes humans but doesn’t kill them. Also, Emily’s journals mention something called “pookie” — an hallucinogenic mushroom used in the brewing of “happy” tea.
[3] Bragi is the Norse god of poetry. In the book Chesley only gives Bragi very few lines of dialog, but they are all in her trademark Gaelic Haiku, such as:
Craven is a banker
without a pound or sou
— irony is not cheap.
[4] Perth County peanuts are notoriously toxic, and may have contributed to the insanity of Clara Wilton Smigglesworth, the Mad Woman of Mount Brydges, who later killed William Thudworth St.John-Smith, Poet of Spidgy-on-the-Thames (who immortalized Chesley’s father in such poems as “Ode to Johnny the Brave”).
[5] A monetary system only slightly more unstable than one which trades credit on unsecured debt.
[6] In a letter he told his long-time friend and later illustrator, William Denslow (W. W. Denslow), “the bathing scene really is quite gripping, if you catch my drift.”